This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License online at www.gutenberg.org/license
From an early proof of the engraving by
GIULIO BONASONI
(In the Print Room of the British Museum)
Of all the many lives of Michael Angelo that have been written, that by his friend and pupil, Ascanio Condivi, is the most valuable. For not only is it a contemporary record, like the lives inserted by Giorgio Vasari in the two editions of his famous book, "The Lives of the Most Eminent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects," published in Florence in 1550 and 1568; but Condivi's work has almost the authority of an autobiography, many phrases are in the same words, as certain letters in the hand of Michael Angelo still in existence, especially those relating to the early life and the ancestry of the master, to his favourite nephew Lionardo, and concerning the whole story of the Tragedy of the Tomb to Francesco Fattucci and others.
Condivi's description of his master's personal appearance is so detailed that we can see him with his sculptor's callipers measuring the head of his dear master, and gazing earnestly into his eyes, recording the colours of their scintillations, with the patience of a painter.
Condivi published his "Vita di Michael Angelo
Buonarroti" on July 16, 1553; probably incited thereto
by the master himself, who desired to correct certain misstatements
of his excellent friend, Giorgio Vasari, without
hurting that worthy's feelings. Nevertheless, we gather
from what Vasari says in his second edition that he somewhat
resented the appearance of this new biographer.
Perhaps this coloured his unflattering account of Condivi
as an artist, when describing Michael Angelo's scholars:
"Ascanio della Ripa took great pains, but no results have
been seen, whether in designs or finished works. He spent
several years over a picture for which Michael Angelo had
given him the cartoon, and, at a word, the hopes conceived
of him have vanished in smoke." What a good thing it
would have been for Vasari's reputation if his art work
had vanished in smoke, too, and only his biographies
A second edition of the "Vita di Michael Angelo," by Ascanio Condivi, was published at Florence in 1746. The introduction informs us that Condivi was born at Ripa Transona, and that he outlived his master ten years, dying on February 17, 1563 (1564), aged nearly eighty-nine years.
The second part of this book may be regarded as an
appendix For convenience of reference the chapters in the two parts are
divided so as to cover the same periods of time in the life of the master.
Since this book went to press, the author has seen an antique intaglio, No. 210 in the Estense Collection at Modena, which he is informed came from Ferrara in 1598, representing a Leda. This confirms the view expressed in the note on page 61, as to the genesis of the Leda by Michael Angelo, for it is exactly similar in composition.
The author desires to express his gratitude to many friends for valuable advice and assistance, especially to his wife for help in the translations, and to Mr. S. Arthur Strong for kindly looking over the proofs, and other aid; to the Earl of Leicester, of Holkham, for permission to photograph and reproduce the Cartoon at Holkham Hall; to the trustees of the British Museum and Mr. Sidney Colvin for facilities to reproduce two engravings in the Print Room; to the Signori Fratelli Alinari, Signor Anderson, Mm. Braun et Cie., and Signor Brogi, for kindly allowing their photographs to be used in making the illustrations.
THE LIFE OF MICHAEL ANGELO BUONARROTI,
BY HIS SCHOLAR ASCANIO CONDIVI,
TRANSLATED BY CHARLES HOLROYD
Michael Angelo Buonarroti, the unique painter and
sculptor, was descended from the Counts of Canossa, a
noble and illustrious family of the land of Reggio, both on
account of their own worth and antiquity, and because
they had Imperial blood in their veins. Count Alessandro da Canossa acknowledged relationship to
Michael Angelo in a letter, dated October 4, 1520 (Gotti, i. 4), addressing
the master as "honoured kinsman," but the relationship
cannot now be proved. The ancestors of Michael Angelo have been
traced to one Bernardo who died before the year 1228, and they played
their part as citizens of Florence, no mean city, for more than two
hundred years—a noble pedigree even for Michael Angelo.
A paid magistrate or mayor, generally from a neighbouring town
or country and not a citizen of the place where he was on duty.sesitiere or sixth
part of the town, for into so many wards was the township
divided at that time; to-day the wards are quartieri or
fourth parts. The Guelph party were in power in Florence,
and he, from Ghibelline that he was, became Guelph,
because of the many benefits he received from that faction,
changing the colour of his coat-of-arms, which originally
was gules, a dog rampant with a bone in his mouth,
argent—to azure, a dog or; and the Signoria afterwards
granted him five lilies, gules, in a Rastrello, and at
the same time the crest with two horns of a bull, the
one or, and the other azure, as may be seen to this day
painted on their ancient shields; the old arms of Messer
Simone may be seen in the palace of the Podestà, carved
in marble by his orders, according to the custom of those
who held that office.
III. The reason why the family in Florence changed
their name from Canossa to de'Buonarroti was because the
name Buonarroto was usual in their house from age to age,
almost always, down to the time of Michael Angelo himself,
who had a brother called Buonarroto, and many of
these Buonarroti being of the Signori, that is of the
supreme magistracy of the Republic; the said brother
especially, who was of that body at the time when Pope
Leo was in Florence, as may be seen in the annals of the
city; this name held by so many of them became a surname
for the whole family, the more easily as it is the
IV. Of such family, then, was Michael Angelo born; his
father's name was Lodovico di Leonardo Buonarroti
Simoni, a good and religious man, somewhat old-fashioned.
Michael Angelo was born to him whilst he was Podestà of
Chiusi and Caprese Caprese is made up of scattered hamlets and farmhouses near
Arezzo, upon the watershed between the Tiber and the Arno. Upon March 6, 1475, according to our present reckoning, Lodovico
wrote in his note-book: "I record that on this day, March 6, 1474, a male child was born to
me. I gave him the name of Michael Angelo, and he was born on a
Monday morning four or five hours before daybreak, and he was born
while I was Podestà of Caprese, and he was born at Caprese; and the
godfathers were those I have named below. He was baptized on the
eighth of the same month in the Church of San Giovanni at Caprese."
Then follow the godfathers; there are ten of them.
V. The child grew and came to be of a reasonable age.
His father, noticing his ability, desired that he should
devote himself to letters; he therefore sent him to the
school of a certain Maestro Francesco da Urbino, who in
those days taught grammar in Florence; Maestro Francesco only taught Michael Angelo to read and write
in the vulgar tongue, for his pupil complained in after life that he
knew no Latin; this was not Francesco's fault, for his pupil soon followed
his friend's—another Francesco—influence and neglected literature
for the art that made him famous. Ghirlandaio, born 1449, died 1494. Martin Schongauer, born at Colmar about 1450, died 1488. When Michael Angelo was thirteen years old Lodovico gave in to
his wishes and apprenticed him to Domenico Ghirlandajo (he was
called Ghirlandajo because as a goldsmith he had made garlands of
golden leaves for the brows of the Florentine ladies) upon the unusual
terms set forth in the following minute from Domenico's ledger under
the date 1488: "I record this first of April how that I,
Lodovico di Lionardo di Buonarrota, bind my son Michael Angelo to
Domenico and Davit di Tommaso di Currado for the next three ensuing
years, under these conditions and contracts: to wit that the said
Michael Angelo shall stay with the above-named masters during this
time, to learn the art of painting, and to practise the same, and
to be at the order of the above-named; and they for their part,
shall give him in the course of these three years twenty-four
florins (fiorini di Sagello, A note of April 16, 1488, records that two florins were paid to
Michael Angelo upon that day. The total sum is estimated by Gotti
(p. 6, note) to equal 206.40 lira present value—about £8 12s.); to wit, six florins in the first year,
eight in the second, ten in the third, making in all the sum of
ninety-six pounds (lire)."£8 12s. It was
usual for apprentices to pay a sum to their masters rather than to be
paid.
VI. Possibly not less wonderful was another labour of
Michael Angelo's done at this time, perhaps as a jest.
Some one lent him a drawing of a head to copy; he returned
his copy to the owner instead of the original and
the deception was not noticed, but the boy talking and
laughing about it with one of his companions it was
found out. Many people compared the two and found no
difference in them, for besides the perfection of the drawing,
Michael Angelo had smoked the paper to make it appear
of the same age as the original. This brought him a
great reputation. Drawings, even by old masters, were of no pecuniary value in
those days; they were merely kept for use in the workshop. The
fashion of collecting drawings for their own sake was invented by
Giorgio Vasari some sixty years later.
VII. Now drawing one thing and now another, the
boy had no fixed plan or method of study. It happened
one day that Granacci took him to the gardens of the
Medici at San Marco. In this garden the Magnificent
There is a mask of a grinning faun to be seen in the Bargello at
Florence, attributed to Michael Angelo and said to be this his first work
in sculpture. It does not correspond with either the account of Vasari
or of Condivi; it is a poor and ugly piece of work, and shows no sign
whatever of the early style of Michael Angelo, but is more likely a work
of a later period by some one who had seen the mask under the left
arm of "The Night" on the tomb of Lorenzo at San Lorenzo.Oh! you have made this Faun very old, and yet
have left him all his teeth: do you not know that old men of that
age always lack some of them?" It seemed a thousand years
to Michael Angelo before the Magnificent went away and
he remained alone to correct his error. He cut away a tooth
from the upper jaw, drilling a hole in the gums as though
it had come out by the roots.Let your father know that I desire to speak
with him."
VIII. When he got home Michael Angelo carried out
the embassy of the Magnificent; his father divining why
he was called, with great persuasion from Granacci and
others made ready to go: lamenting to himself that his
son would be taken away. Stating, moreover, that he
would never suffer his son to be a stonemason, it was
useless for Granacci to explain how great was the difference
between a sculptor and a mason. After all this long
"During this time Michael Angelo received from the Magnifico an
allowance of five ducats per month, and was furthermore presented for
his gratification with a violet-coloured mantle. But, indeed, all the
young men who studied in the gardens received stipends of greater or
less amount from the liberality of that Magnificent and most noble
citizen, being constantly encouraged and rewarded by him whilst he
lived." (Vasari.) Many motives from antique gems may be traced in the art of
Michael Angelo, such as the Judith and her maid, some of the athletes
the Leda, and even the Adam.Even
so," he replied, "not only Michael Angelo, but all of us,
with our lives and all our best faculties, are at the service of
your Magnificence." And when the Magnificent asked
what he could do for himself, he replied: "I have never
practised any profession; but have always lived upon my
small income and attended to the small property left to me
by my ancestors; trying not only to keep it up properly, but
also endeavouring to increase it as far as I may with my
powers and by my diligence." The Magnificent then replied:
"Very well, look about you, see if there is not something
in Florence that will suit you; make use of me; I
will do the best I can for you." And so dismissing the old
man, he gave Michael Angelo a good room in his own
house with all that he needed,
IX. Michael Angelo was between fifteen and sixteen
years of age when he entered the house of the Magnificent,
and he stayed with him until his death, which was in
ninety-two, Lorenzo died upon the eighth day of April, 1492. Equal to-day to 20.60 lire—about seventeen shillings.Lorenzo, I can do nothing but read and write; the comrade
of Marco Pucci in the Dogana is dead. I should like
to have his place. I believe I shall be able to carry out the
duties properly." The Magnificent put his hand upon his
shoulder and, smiling, said: "You will always be poor,"
for he expected that he would ask for some great thing.
However, he continued, "If you will be the comrade of
Marco, be it so, till something better turns up." This place
brought him eight scudi
X. In the meantime Michael Angelo prosecuted his
studies, showing the result of his labours to the Magnificent
each day. In the same house lived Poliziano, a man,
Nineteen and a quarter inches according to the measurements of
Heath Wilson ("Michael Angelo and his Works," p. 17, ed. 1881). This
relief is in the Casa Buonarroti, Florence. We have no record of this work, and its whereabouts is not
known.
The boy, Michael Angelo, probably enjoyed this frolic and its
attendant festivities as much as Piero, he could not have done much
other work in the dungeon-like studios of Florence in such cold weather.
This incident has been regarded as an insult to the artist and a sign of
Piero's want of taste. Michael Angelo cannot have felt aggrieved as he
stayed on at the palace. Condivi relates that he remained "some
months." Piero should rather be blamed for not employing his artist
guest upon some more lasting work also.
XII. Lodovico, the father of Michael Angelo, now
became more friendly to his son, seeing that he was almost
always in the society of great personages, and he dressed
him in finer clothes. The youth lived with Piero some
months and was much caressed by him. Piero used to
say, boastingly, that he had two remarkable men in
his establishment: one was Michael Angelo, and the
other a certain Spanish groom who, besides being
marvellously beautiful to look upon, was so nimble and
strong and so long-winded that, let Piero ride as fast
XIII. At this time, Michael Angelo, to please the
Prior of Santo Spirito, a church much venerated in
Florence, carved a crucifix in wood, a little under life size,
which to this day may be seen over the high altar of that
church. Nothing is known as to the fate of this work, it is not now in the
church. Vasari states that Michael Angelo devoted much time to the study
of anatomy. "For the church of Santo Spirito, in Florence, Michael
Angelo made a crucifix in wood, which is placed over the lunette of the
high altar. This he did to please the Prior, who had given him a
room wherein he dissected many dead bodies, zealously studying
anatomy." (Vasari.) A pen drawing at Oxford shows us two students studying anatomy
at night; the body of the subject supports the torch; one student
holds a pair of compasses in his right hand for measuring the
proportions.
XIV. There was living in the house of Piero a certain
man named Cardiere, who had been very acceptable to the
Magnifico, he improvised songs to the lyre most marvellously;
in fact, he made a profession of it, and practised
his art nearly every evening after supper. This man was
friendly with Michael Angelo and imparted to him a
vision, which was this: That Lorenzo de' Medici had
You must be mad!
Do you think Lorenzo would rather appear to you or to his
own son? Would he not rather appear to him than to any
one else?" They ridiculed him and let him go. He
went home and bemoaned himself to Michael Angelo,
and he spoke so effectually of the vision, holding that
the thing was true, that two days afterwards with two
XV. In a few days lack of funds (his companions
having spent all his money) made Michael Angelo think
of returning to Florence; but coming to Bologna a curious
chance hindered them. Now there was a law in that
land in the time of Messer Giovanni Bentivogli that every
stranger who entered into Bologna should be obliged to
have a great seal of red wax impressed upon his nail.
Michael Angelo inadvertently entered without being
sealed, so he was conducted, together with his companions,
to the office of the Bullette, and condemned to pay a fine
of fifty Bolognese lire: not having the wherewithal he
was obliged to remain at the office. A certain Bolognese
gentleman, Messer Gian Francesco Aldovrandi, who was
then of the Sixteen, seeing him there, and hearing the
reason, liberated him, chiefly because he was a sculptor.
Aldovrandi invited the sculptor to his house. Michael
Angelo thanked him, but excused himself because he had
two companions with him who would not leave him, and
he would not burden the gentleman with their company.
To this the gentleman replied: "I, too, will come and
wander over the world with you, if you will pay my
expenses." With these and other words he prevailed over
Michael Angelo, who excused himself to his companions
and took leave of them, gave them what little money he
had, and went to lodge with the gentleman.
XVI. By this time the House of the Medici, with all
XVII. One day walking together in Bologna they went
to see the ark of San Domenico, in the Church dedicated
to that Saint; two marble figures were still lacking, a San
Petronio and a kneeling angel supporting a candlestick in
his arms. The gentleman asked Michael Angelo if he
had the heart to undertake them, and he replying "yes,"
had it arranged that he should have them to do; he was
paid thirty ducats for it, eighteen for the San Petronio,
and twelve for the angel. The figures were three palms high;
they may still be seen in that same place. But afterwards
Michael Angelo mistrusted a Bolognese sculptor, who complained
that he had taken away the commission for the
before-mentioned statues from him, as it had first been
promised to him, and as he threatened to do him an injury
Michael Angelo left Bologna hastily under fear of personal violence
from the sculptors and native craftsmen, who said he was taking
the bread out of their mouths, rather a strong compliment to a boy of
twenty.
XVIII. Having returned to his native town Michael
Angelo set to work to carve out of marble a god of Love,
between six and seven years of age, lying asleep; this
figure was seen by Lorenzo di Pier Francesco de' Medici
(for whom in the meantime Michael Angelo had carved a
little Saint John), and he judged that it was most beautiful
and said of it: " The dealer Baldassari del Milanese paid Michael Angelo thirty
ducats for this work, and sold it to Raffaello Riario, Cardinal di San
Giorgio, as an antique for two hundred ducats, an evidence, not of the
Cardinal's foolishness, but of Michael Angelo's careful study of the
antique. The Cardinal S. Giorgio made Messer Baldassari refund the two
hundred ducats and take the Cupid back, so Michael Angelo got nothing
for his journey. Cesare Borgia presented this Cupid to Guidobaldo di
Montefeltro, Duke of Urbino. After Cesare Borgia sacked the town of
Urbino in 1592 he sent the Cupid to the Marchioness of Mantua, who
wrote on July 22, 1592, describing the Cupid as "without a peer among
the works of modern times." There is a sleeping Cupid at Mantua in
the Museo Civico, but it is not by Michael Angelo. Signor Fabriczy
holds that a Cupid preserved in the museum at Turin may be Michael
Angelo's original work, but the translator has not seen it. Michael Angelo arrived in Rome for the first time at the end
of June 1496, and wrote in July to Lorenzo di' Pier Francesco de'
Medici. The letter bears a superscription to Sandro Botticelli; historians
presume from this that it was not safe to write openly to any of the
Medici. "2nd day of July, 1496. "Magnificent Lorenzo,—I only write to inform you that last
Saturday we arrived safely, and went at once to visit the Cardinal di
San Giorgio; and I presented your letter to him. It appeared to me
that he was pleased to see me, and he expressed a wish that I should
go immediately to inspect his collection of statues. I spent the whole
day there, and for that reason was unable to deliver all your letters.
On Sunday the Cardinal came into the new house, and had me sent
for. I went to him, and he asked me what I thought about the things
I had seen. I replied by stating my opinion, and certainly I can say
with sincerity that there are many fine things in the collection. Then
he asked me if I had the courage to make some beautiful work. I
answered that I should not be able to achieve anything so great, but
that he should see what I could do. We have bought a piece of marble
for a life size statue, and on Monday I shall begin to work. On Monday
last I presented your other letter of recommendation to Rucellai, who
offered me what money I might want; also those to Cavalcanti. Afterwards
I gave your letter to Baldassare, and asked him for the child
(the sleeping Cupid), saying I was ready to refund his money. He
answered very roughly, swearing he would rather break it in a hundred
pieces; he had bought the child and it was his property; he possessed
writing which proved that he had satisfied the person who sent
it to him, and was under no apprehension that he should have to give
it up. Then he complained bitterly of you, saying that you had
spoken ill of him. Certain of our Florentines sought to accommodate
matters, but failed in their attempt. Now I look to coming to terms
through the Cardinal; for this is the advice of Baldassare Balducci.
What ensues I will report to you. No more by this. To you I recommend
myself. May God keep you from evil. "Michael Angelo, in Rome. "To Sandro Botticelli, at Florence." (Gotti, ii. 32.)If you can manage to make it look as if it
had been buried under the earth I will forward it to Rome,
it will be taken for an antique and you will sell it much better."
Michael Angelo hearing this immediately prepared it as
one from whom no craft was hidden, so that it looked as if
it had been made many years ago. In this state it was
sent to Rome; the Cardinal di San Giorgio bought it as
an antique for two hundred ducats; though the man who
took all that money only paid thirty ducats to Michael
Angelo as what he had received for the Cupid. So much
of a rogue was he that he deceived at the same time both
Lorenzo di Pier Francesco and Michael Angelo.
This ugly, but marvellously-finished statue is now in the western
corridor of the Uffizi, in Florence. See p. 107. See p. 108.
XX. A little afterwards, at the request of the Cardinal
de San Dionigi (called the Cardinal Rovano), he carved
from a block of marble that marvellous statue of our
Lady, which is now in the church of the Madonna della
Febbre; The work is now in the first chapel on the right in the nave of
the Basilica of Saint Peter's.Do you not know," he said, "that chaste women retain
their fresh looks much longer than those who are not chaste?
How much more, therefore, a virgin in whom not even the
least unchaste desire ever arose? And I tell you, moreover,
that such freshness and flower of youth besides being maintained
in her by natural causes, it may possibly be that it was
ordained by the Divine Power to prove to the world the virginity
and perpetual purity of the Mother. It was not necessary
in the Son; but rather the contrary; wishing to show
that the Son of God took upon himself a true human body
subject to all the ills of man, excepting only sin; he did not
allow the divine in him to hold back the human, but let it run
its course and obey its laws, as was proved in His appointed
time. Do not wonder then that I have, for all these reasons,
made the most Holy Virgin, Mother of God, a great deal
younger in comparison with her Son than she is usually
represented. To the Son I have allotted His full age." Considerations
worthy of any theologian, wonderful perhaps in
any one else, but not in Michael Angelo, whom God and
Nature have formed not only for his unique craftsmanship,
but also capable of any, the most divine, conceptions, as
may be seen not only in this but in very many of his
arguments and writings. He may have been twenty-four
or twenty-five years old when he finished this work. He
gained great fame and reputation by it, so that already, in
the opinion of the world, not only did he greatly surpass
all others of the time and of the times before, but also he
challenged the ancients themselves.
XXI. These works being finished, he had to return to
Florence for family affairs; he stayed there long enough
to carve the statue called by all men the Giant, which
is placed to this day by the door of the Palazzo della
Signoria at the end of the balustrade. Now in the Accademia delle Belle Arti of Florence, where it was
placed for its better preservation in 1831. The Office of Works. Documents, copies of which are to be found in "Gaye," vol. ii.
pp. 454-464, go to prove that this sculptor was Agostino di Antonio di
Duccio, who was born in 1418 and died in 1481. He was the author of
the relief illustrating the life of S. Gemignano upon the façade of the
Duomo at Modena, and some of the beautiful and delicate marble
reliefs set in the polychromatic front of the Oratory of S. Bernardino at
Perugia, and the fairy-like low relief (bassissimi rilievi) panels that
decorate the interior of the temple of Malatesta at Rimini.
XXII. In order that no copy of the Giant should
exist which was not his own handiwork, he had it cast in
bronze, of the size of the original, for his good friend Pier
Soderini, who sent it to France; and similarly he cast a
David with Goliath under him. The one to be seen in
the middle of the court-yard of the Palazzo de'Signori is
by Donatello, a man excellent in his art, and much praised
by Michael Angelo, except for one thing—he had not the
The Madonna and Child in the church of Notre Dame at Bruges,
identified as this work, is in marble. Vasari also states that the work
for the Moscheroni, Merchants of Bruges, was a bronze, but both
accounts were written fifty years after the event. Albert Dürer saw
this work in the church and mentions it as a marble statue in his
"Netherlands Diary," 1520-21. Now in the Tribuna of the Uffizi, Florence.
XXIII. It was some time since he had worked at that
art, having given himself up to the study of poets and
authors in the vulgar tongue and writing sonnets for his
own pleasure. After the death of Pope Alexander VI. he
was called to Rome by Pope Julius II., and received a
hundred ducats in Florence as his viaticum. At this
time Michael Angelo was about twenty-nine years old;
for if we count from his birth in 1474, already stated, to
the death of the above Alexander, which was in 1503, we
shall find the number of years as given.
XXIV. Coming then to Rome, many months Michael Angelo received payment for the cartoon probably in
Florence on February the 28th, 1505 ("Gaye," ii., p. 93), and he went
to Carrara in April of that year, so the delay was only two months, a
short enough time to prepare his great design. The right bank of the Tiber below Rome. On the opposite shore
is the Marmorata, where blocks of marble were unloaded in the times of
the ancient Romans; some are there to this day. The covered way from the Vatican to the Castle of Saint Angelo.
XXV. These many and frequent favours were the
cause (as often is the case at Court) of much envy, and,
after the envy, of endless persecution, since Bramante,
the architect, who was much loved by the Pope, made him
change his mind as to the monument by telling him, as is
said by the vulgar, that it is unlucky to build one's tomb
in one's lifetime. Fear as well as envy stimulated
Heath Wilson estimates the area it would have covered as 34-1/2 ft.
by 23 ft. (p. 74).
XXVI. And to give some idea of it, I say briefly that
this tomb was to have had four faces, two of eighteen
XXVII. Having seen this design the Pope sent Michael
Angelo to Saint Peter's to decide where it might most
conveniently be erected. The church was in the form of
What would be the cost of this?" Michael Angelo
replied, "One hundred thousand scudi." "Let it be two
hundred thousand," said Julius. And sending San Gallo,
the architect, and Bramante to see the place, by their
suggestion it came into the mind of the Pope to rebuild
the church altogether. He directed them to prepare
designs, and that of Bramante was approved, as being
more graceful and better understood than the others.
Thus, Michael Angelo was the cause, both that those
parts of the building already begun were completed,
which otherwise might have remained as they were to
this day, and that it came into the mind of the Pope
to rebuild the rest of the church on a more magnificent
scale.
XXVIII. Returning to our story, Michael Angelo became
acquainted with the change in the wishes of Julius
in the following manner: The Pope instructed Michael
Angelo that if he needed money he was to come direct to
him and not to others, so that he might not have to go
from one to another for it. It happened one day that the
rest of the marbles that had been left at Carrara arrived
at the Ripa; Michael Angelo had them disembarked and
carried to Saint Peter's, and desiring at once to pay the
Pardon me, I have
been ordered not to admit you." A bishop was present,
and hearing the words of the man, cried out: "You cannot
know who this man is?" "I know him very well,"
replied the groom, "but I am obliged to do what I am
bid by my masters without further question." Michael
Angelo, who had never before been kept waiting or had
the door barred against him, seeing himself so turned off
and scorned, was angered and replied: "You may tell
the Pope that, henceforward, if he wants me he must look
for me elsewhere." So he returned to his house and instructed
his two servants to sell all his furniture, and when
they got the money to follow him to Florence. He himself
took horse and at the second hour of the night reached
Poggibonsi, a castle in the Florentine territory, eighteen
or twenty miles from the city, where, as in a safe place, he
rested.
XXIX. A little later five messengers from Pope Julius
arrived with orders to bring Michael Angelo back wherever
they might find him. But overtaking him in a place
where they were unable to offer him any violence,
Michael Angelo threatening them with death if they
XXX. Pier Soderini, who was then Gonfaloniere of
the Republic for life, having formerly let him go to Rome
much against his will, wished him to work for him by
painting in the Sala del Consiglio. On receipt of the first
Brief he did not oblige Michael Angelo to return, hoping
that the anger of the Pope would abate; but when a
second and a third arrived, he called Michael Angelo to
him and said: "You have braved the Pope as the King
of France would not have done, therefore prayer is unavailing.
We do not wish to go to war with him on your
account and risk the State, so prepare yourself to return."
Michael Angelo fled from Rome during the week after Easter, 1506. He relates the circumstances in a letter of October 1542, No. c. d. xxxv. "Le Lettere p. 489," which corroborates Condivi's story word for word, and is another proof of the autobiographical nature of these memoirs.
XXXI. Whilst he was still in Florence two things
happened. One was that he finished the marvellous
cartoon he had begun for the Sala del Consiglio, which
represented the war between Florence and Pisa, and the
many and various events that occurred in it, which cartoon
of consummate art was a light to all those who
afterwards took pencil in hand. I cannot tell what evil
fortune happened to it afterwards, it was left by Michael
Angelo in the Sala del Papa (a place so called in Florence)
at Santa Maria Novella. Fragments of it can be seen in
No fragments of this cartoon remain; perhaps the best copy is
that in possession of the Earl of Leicester at Holkham Hall. See also
p. 124.
XXXII. So he arrived at Bologna one morning, and
going to San Petronio to hear mass, Like the good Catholic he was, he went to hear mass as soon as
he had completed his journey; he always behaved as a good son of the
Church.You ought to have come to
us, and you have waited for us to come to you." Meaning
to say, that his Holiness being come to Bologna, a place
much nearer to Florence than Rome is, it was as if he (the
Pope) had come to him. Michael Angelo with a loud
voice and on his knees craved pardon, pleading that he
had not erred maliciously but through indignation, for he
could not bear to be hunted away as he had been. The
Pope kept his head lowered and replied nothing, to all
appearances much troubled, when a certain monsignore,
sent by the Cardinal Soderini to excuse and intercede for
Michael Angelo, broke in, saying: "Your Holiness, do
not remember his fault, for he has erred through
ignorance; these painters in things outside their art are
all like this." The Pope indignantly replied: "You
abuse him, whilst we say nothing; you are the ignorant
one, and he is not the culprit; take yourself off in an evil
hour." But as he was not going, he was, as Michael
Angelo used to tell, hustled out of the room with blows
by the servants of the Pope. Thus the Pope having spent
his fury on the bishop, called Michael Angelo closer to
him, and pardoned him, ordering him not to leave Bologna
until another commission had been given to him. Nor
was he long before he sent for him and said that he
wished Michael Angelo to make a great portrait statue of
him in bronze, which he wished to place on the front of
the Church of San Petronio. And he left a thousand
ducats in the bank of Messer Antommaria da Lignano to
carry out the work when he departed for Rome. It is true
that before he left Michael Angelo had already modelled
it in clay, but he was doubtful as to what the statue
should hold in the left hand, the right was raised as if
giving a benediction. He asked the Pope, who had come
to see the statue, if it pleased him that he should be
made holding a book. "
XXXIII. After he had finished this work he went to
Rome, where Pope Julius wished to employ him, keeping
still to his purpose of not going on with his tomb. It was
put into his head by Bramante and other rivals of Michael
Angelo that he should make him paint the vault of the
chapel of Sixtus the Fourth, in the Vatican, making him
believe that he would do wonders. This was done
maliciously, to distract the Pope from works of sculpture;
and because they thought it was certain, either, that by his
not accepting such a commission, he would stir up the
Pope's anger against himself, or that by accepting it he
would come out of it very much inferior to Raffaello da
Urbino, whom they heaped with favours on account of
their hatred for Michael Angelo, judging that his principal
art was sculpture, as in truth it was. Michael Angelo,
who as yet had never used colours and knew the painting
of the vault to be a very difficult undertaking, tried with
all his power to get out of it, proposing Raffaello and
excusing himself, in that it was not his art and that he
would not succeed, refusing so many demands that the
Pope was almost in a passion. But seeing his obstinacy,
Michael Angelo set himself to do the work, which to-day
is seen in the palace of the Pope, and is the admiration and
XXXIV. The shape of this ceiling is what is commonly
called a barrel vaulting, resting on lunettes, six to the
length and two to the width of the building, so that the
whole formed two squares and a half. In this space
Michael Angelo has depicted, firstly, the creation of the
world, and then almost the whole of the Old Testament.
He has divided the work after this fashion: Beginning
at the brackets, where the horns of the lunettes rest, up to
almost a third of the arch of the vault, the walls appear
to continue flat, running up to that height with certain
pilasters and plinths imitating marble, which project into
the open like a balustrade over an additional storey, with
corbels below, and with other little pilasters above the
same storey, where sit the prophets and sybils. The
first pilasters grow from the arches of the lunettes, placing
the pedestals in the middle, leaving, however, the greater
part of the arch of the lunette—that is to say, the space
they contain between them. Above the said plinths are
painted some little naked children in various poses, who,
in guise of terminals, support a cornice, which binds the
whole work together, leaving in the middle of the vault
from end to end, as it were, the open sky. This opening
is divided into nine spaces; for from the cornices over the
pilasters spring certain arches with cornices, which traverse
the highest part of the vault, and join the cornice on the
opposite side of the chapel, leaving from arch to arch nine
openings, large and small. In the smaller spaces are two
fillets, painted like marble that cross the opening in such
This composition is generally known as the "Sacrifice of Noah,"
see p. 172. Condivi evidently did not refer these descriptions to the
master, they are so full of curious individualities of his own. That is the picture right. The picture right, i.e., the spectator's left.
XXXV. But no less marvellous is that part which does not relate to the histories at all, that is to say, certain nudes who sit upon plinths above the before-mentioned cornice, one on either side holding up the medallions, which, as has been said, appear to be of metal, on which, in the style of reverses, are designed several stories, all however appropriate to their principal histories. By the beauty of the divisions, by the variety of the poses, and by the balance of the proportionate parts, in all of them Michael Angelo exhibited the highest art. But to tell the particulars of these things would be an infinite labour, a book to them alone would not be enough; therefore I pass over them briefly, wishing rather to give a little light upon the whole than to detail the parts.
XXXVI. In the meanwhile he did not lack troubles;
for, having finished the picture of the Deluge, the work
began to grow mouldy, "To bloom," as a painter of to-day would say.I have already
told your Holiness that this is not my art; all that I have
done is spoiled; if you do not believe it send and see." The
Pope sent Il San Gallo, who, when he examined the fresco,
saw that the plaster had been applied too wet, and the
dampness running down caused this effect; and informing
Michael Angelo of this he made him proceed, and the
excuse was unavailing.
XXXVII. Whilst he was painting Pope Julius went
to see the work many times, ascending the scaffolding by a
ladder, Michael Angelo giving him his hand to assist him
on to the highest platform. And, like one who was of a
vehement nature, and impatient of delay, when but one
half of the work was done, the part from the door to the
middle of the vault, See p. 163.
XXXVIII. After this, Raphael, having seen this new
and marvellous manner as one who excelled in imitating,
tried by the aid of Bramante to get the rest of the chapel
to paint. Michael Angelo was much troubled, came
before the Pope, and bitterly complained of the injury
Bramante was doing him; and in his presence grieved over
it with the Pope, discovering to him all the persecution
he had suffered from him, and afterwards unfolded to him
See pp. 147-165 and 183. The first half may be estimated to have
taken eight months and a few days, and the second half from January
1510 to October 1512, with intervals for journeys to Florence, to Bologna,
and other interruptions. That is professional assistance by artists or pupils. Workmen
were employed to plaster each day's section of work, writers to do the
lettering, and even decorative workmen for architectural details.When I can." The
Pope, angered, added: "Do you want me to have you
thrown down off this scaffolding?" Michael Angelo, hearing
this, said to himself: "Nay, you shall not have me
thrown down," and as soon as the Pope had gone away he
had the scaffolding taken down and uncovered his work
upon All Saints Day. It was seen with great satisfaction
by the Pope (who that very day visited the chapel), and all
Rome crowded to admire it. It lacked the retouches "a
secco" of ultramarine and of gold in certain places, which
It should be touched with gold," replied the
Pope. Michael Angelo said to him familiarly, as he had
a way of doing with his Holiness: "I do not see that men
wear gold." The Pope again said: "It will seem poor."
"Those who are painted here were poor also," Michael
Angelo replied. This he threw out in jest; but so the
vault has remained. Michael Angelo received for this
work and all his expenses three thousand ducats, of which
I have heard him say he spent in colours about twenty or
twenty-five.
XXXIX. When he had finished this work Michael
Angelo, because he had painted so long a time with his
eyes turned upwards towards the vault, could hardly see
anything when looking down, so that when he had to read
a letter or look at a minute object it was necessary for
him to hold it above his head. Nevertheless, little by
little, he became able to again read looking down. By
this we are able to judge with how much attention and
assiduity he had carried out his work. Many other
things happened to him during the life of Pope Julius,
who loved him from his heart, having a more jealous care
for him than for any one else he had about him, as one
may see clearly by what we have already written. Indeed,
one day fearing that Michael Angelo was angry, he
immediately sent to pacify him. It happened in this
wise. Michael Angelo wanting to go to Florence for
Saint John's Day asked the Pope for money; and he
demanded when his chapel would be finished. Michael
Angelo, as his custom was, replied, " These quarries are in the Alpi Apuane near Viareggio, we are
informed by a modern Florentine sculptor that this marble is of
excellent quality. See pp. 183-185. This column was still lying in the Piazza of San Lorenzo in 1888;
it has now been removed.When I can." The
Pope, who was of a hasty nature, struck him with a stick
that he had in his hand, saying: "When I can, indeed;
when I can!" After he got home Michael Angelo was
preparing, without more ado, to go to Florence, when
Leave me to deal with them; I will
content them." So he sent for both of them and made
them release Michael Angelo, much to the sorrow both of
himself and the Cardinals, especially of Aginense, nephew,
as has been said, of Pope Julius, for whom, however,
Pope Leo promised that Michael Angelo should work in
Florence, and that he would not hinder him. In this
fashion, weeping, Michael Angelo left the tomb and
betook himself to Florence. As soon as he arrived he
put everything in order for building the façade, he himself
went to Carrara to transport marbles, not only for the
façade but also for the tomb, relying upon the promise
of the Pope that he would be able to go on with it. In
the meantime the Pope was informed that in the mountains
of Pietrasanta, in the Florentine territory, there were
marbles as good and beautiful as at Carrara. When this
was discussed with Michael Angelo, he, as a friend of the
Marchese Alberigo, and having come to an understanding
with him about the marbles, preferred rather to quarry at
Carrara than at these new places in the State of Florence.
The Pope wrote to Michael Angelo and commanded him
to go to Pietrasanta and see if it was as he heard from
Florence. He went there and found the marble very
unmanageable and unsuitable;
XL. Now having returned to Florence, and finding, as
was said before, that the fervour of Pope Leo was all
spent, Michael Angelo, grieving, remained there doing
nothing for a long while, having, first in one thing and
then in another, thrown away much of his time, to his
great annoyance. Nevertheless, with certain blocks of
marble that he had placed in his own house, he proceeded
with the work of the Tomb. But Leo departing this life,
Adrian was created Pope, and the work was interrupted
again, for they charged Michael Angelo with having
received from Julius for this work quite sixteen thousand
scudi, and that he did not trouble himself to get on with
it, but stayed at Florence for his own pleasure. All these
accusations called for his presence in Rome; but the
Cardinal de' Medici, who afterwards became Pope
Clement VII., and who then had the government of
Florence in his hand, did not wish him to go; and to
keep him employed, and to have an excuse, he made him
begin the Medici Library in San Lorenzo, and at the same
time the sacristy with the tombs of his ancestors, promising
to satisfy the Pope for him, and arrange matters.
Then Adrian living only a few months and Clement
succeeding him in the Papacy, nothing more was said
XLI. In the meantime the House of Medici was driven
out of Florence by the opposing faction, because they had
taken more authority to themselves than could be suffered
in a free city that ruled herself by her Republic. As the
Signoria did not expect that the Pope would do anything
to forego his family's authority they expected certain war,
and turned their minds to the fortifications of their city,
and appointed Michael Angelo Commissary-General for
that work. He then, accepting this preferment, besides
many other preparations carried out by him on every side
of the city, encircled with strong fortifications the hill of
San Miniato, that stands above the city and overlooks the
surrounding plain. If the enemy took this hill nothing
could prevent him becoming master of the city also. This
fort was judged to be the saving of the country, and very
dangerous to the enemy; being, as I have said, of high
XLII. When Michael Angelo saw how little his word
was considered, and how the ruin of the city was certain, by
the authority he had he caused a gate to be opened, and went
out with two of his people, and betook himself to Venice.
And certainly this notion of a treachery was no fable; but
he who arranged it judged that it would pass over with
less disgrace if it was not discovered just then, as time
would achieve the same result by his merely failing in his
duty and hindering others who wished to do theirs. The
departure of Michael Angelo was the occasion of many
rumours, and he fell into great disgrace with the governors.
All the same, he was recalled with many prayers, with
XLIII. Again in Florence the first thing he did was to protect the bell-tower of San Miniato, which was all broken by the continual cannonading of the enemy, and had become very dangerous to those within. The method of defence was in this wise: a large number of mattresses, well filled with wool, were slung with stout cords from the top of the tower to the bottom, covering parts likely to be hit. And as the cornice projected considerably, the mattresses hung out from the main wall of the bell-tower more than six hands, so that the cannon-balls of the enemy, partly on account of the distance from which they were fired, and partly by the opposition of these mattresses, did little or no damage, not even injuring the mattresses themselves, because they were so yielding. Thus he held that tower all the time of the siege, which lasted a year, without its suffering any injury, and rejoicing greatly in the salvation of the land and the damage he did to the enemy.
XLIV. But afterwards the enemy entered the city by
treachery, and many of the citizens were taken and killed.
The court sent to the house of Michael Angelo to seize
Michael Angelo's love for Lorenzo the Magnificent never abated,
and these tombs may be regarded as a tribute to his early patron's
memory. He worked upon them in secret during the siege itself.
XLV. The statues are four, placed in a sacristy erected
for this purpose on the left of the church opposite the old
sacristy; and although each figure balances the other in
design and general shape, nevertheless, they are quite
different in form, idea, and action. The sarcophagi are placed
against the side walls, and above their lids recline two
figures, larger than life—that is to say, a man and a woman,
signifying Day and Night; and by the two of them Time,
Condivi had not seen this sacristy and described it merely from
the fragmentary recollections of the master.
XLVI. For all that Michael Angelo lived in great fear,
because he was greatly disliked by the Duke Alessandro, a
young man, as every one knows, very fierce and vindictive.
There is no doubt that, if it had not been for the fear of
the Pope, he would have had him put away long ago; the
more so, as this Duke of Florence, when erecting those
XLVII. But before I say any more about this it behoves
me to write of another fact concerning Michael Angelo,
which I have inadvertently omitted. After the violent
departure of the Medici from Florence, the Signoria fearing,
as I have said above, the coming war, and intending
to fortify their city, sent for Michael Angelo, as they knew
him to be a man of consummate ingenuity and most active
in whatever he undertook; nevertheless, by the advice of
certain citizens who favoured the cause of the Medici and
wished covertly to hinder or delay the fortification of the
city, they sent him to Ferrara, under pretext that he should
study the system by which Duke Alfonso had armed and
fortified his city, knowing that his Excellency was most
Possibly in the Duke's collection there may have been an antique
gem engraved with the story of Leda which influenced Michael Angelo
in his choice of this classical subject for the picture he painted for the
Duke. The best version of this picture is in one the offices of the National
Gallery, London; it is probably the much restored original which was
supposed to have been destroyed by order of M. Desnoyers. See p. 204.Michael
Angelo, you are my prisoner. If you want me to let you
go free you must promise to do some work for me with your
own hands, whatever suits you best, let it be what you will,
sculpture or painting." Michael Angelo agreed, and returned
to Florence. Although much occupied in arming the
country, yet he began a large easel picture, representing
Leda and the Swan, and near by the egg from which Castor
and Pollux were born, as is fabled by ancient writers.
When the Duke heard that the Medici had entered
Florence, fearing to lose so great a treasure in the tumult,
he immediately sent one of his own people. His man, when
he came to the house of Michael Angelo and saw the
picture, said: "Why! this is but a small matter." Michael
Angelo asked him what his business was? Realising that
every one thinks they know other people's business best, he
replied simpering, "I am a merchant;" perhaps disgusted by
You ask what is my business, would you
ever believe that I am a merchant?" Michael Angelo heard
what he said, and replied: "You have done bad business for
your lord; leave my sight." So having dismissed the Ducal
messenger, he gave the picture shortly afterwards to one
of his assistants, who had two sisters to marry off. It was
sent into France, where it still is,
XLVIII. Now to return, Michael Angelo having been
called to Rome by Pope Clement, thereupon began the
affair with the Duke of Urbino's agents concerning the
Tomb of Julius. Clement, who wished to employ him in
Florence, tried by every means to free him, and gave him
for his attorney one Messer Tommaso, of Prato, who afterwards
became Datario. But Michael Angelo, who knew
and feared the ill-will of Duke Alessandro towards him,
and at the same time loved and revered the bones of Pope
Julius, and all the illustrious House della Rovere, did all
he could to remain in Rome and work at the Tomb; the
more so because he was accused by every one of having
received from Pope Julius for that purpose fully sixteen
thousand scudi, and of having enjoyed it without doing
what he had undertaken. As he held his honour dear he
could not bear the disgrace, and desired that the affair
should be cleared up, not refusing, although he was old,
Come, tell me, you wish to complete this
tomb; but you want to know who is to pay for the rest of
it." Michael Angelo, who knew the Pope's mind, and that
he wished to make use of him himself, replied: "And what
if some one were found who would pay me?" Pope Clement
said to him: "You are quite mad if you imagine that any
one is likely to come forward to offer you a penny." So
when Messer Tommaso, his attorney, appeared in court
making his proposition to the agents of the Duke, they
began to look one another in the face, and determined
together that some sort of tomb should be made for the
money that had already been advanced. Michael Angelo,
thinking well of it, consented willingly, moved chiefly by
the influence of the Cardinal of Montevecchio, a follower
of Julius II. and uncle to Julius III., now, thanks be to
God, our Pontiff. The agreement was: That Michael
Angelo should make a tomb with one façade only, and
that he should use the marbles already carved for the
quadrangular tomb, arranging them as best he could; and
that he should supply six statues from his own hand. It
was conceded to Pope Clement that Michael Angelo should
serve him in Florence, or wheresoever he pleased, four
months in the year, his Holiness requiring this for the
work in Florence. Such was the contract agreed upon
between his Excellency the Duke and Michael Angelo.
L. Meanwhile Pope Clement died and Paul III. was
elected. He sent for Michael Angelo and requested him
to serve him. Michael Angelo, fearing that he would be
hindered in the work of the Tomb, replied that he could
not, for he was engaged by contract to the Duke of
Urbino until he had finished the work that he had in
hand. The Pope was much annoyed, and said: "It is
some thirty years that I have had this wish, shall I not
satisfy it now I am Pope? Where is the contract that I
may tear it up?" Michael Angelo, seeing it had come to
this, was for leaving Rome and betaking himself to the
country about Genoa, to an abbey of the Bishops of
Aleria, to a follower of Julius, very much his friend,
and there bring his work to an end. This place was conveniently
near Carrara and good for carrying the marbles
by sea. He thought also of going to Urbino, where he
had formerly designed to live, as a quiet resting-place, and
where, for the sake of Julius, he would be welcomed cordially.
For this reason he had sent one of his men some
months before to buy a house and some land; but fearing
the greatness of the Pontiff, with good reason, he did not
go, and hoped with soft words to satisfy the Pope.
This statue alone
is enough to do honour to the Tomb of Pope Julius." When
Pope Paul had seen everything he again asked Michael
Angelo, in the presence of the Cardinals, including the
before-mentioned Most Reverend and Illustrious of Mantua,
to come and work for him, but finding Michael Angelo
obdurate, he said: "I will arrange that the Duke of
Urbino shall be satisfied with these statues by your hand,
and that the three remaining ones shall be given to others
to do." He obtained a new contract from the agents,
confirmed by his Excellency the Duke, who did not wish
to displease the Pope. Although Michael Angelo might
have avoided paying for these three statues, this contract
freeing him from the obligation, nevertheless he wished to
bear the expense himself, and he deposited for these and
the remaining works of the Tomb one thousand five hundred
and eighty ducats. Thus the agents of the Duke
allowed it, and the Tragedy of the Tomb and the Tomb
itself had an end at last. To-day it may be seen in the
Church of San Pietro ad Vincula, not according to the
first design with four sides, but with one side, and that
one of the lesser, not detached all round and isolated,
but built up against a wall on account of the hindrances
mentioned above. It is yet true that, although it is
LII. Now that is enough for this work; indeed, I fear it
is only too much, and that instead of giving pleasure it
will have been tedious to the reader. Nevertheless, it
appeared to me necessary, in order to remove those unfortunate
and false scandals, rooted in men's minds, that
Michael Angelo had received sixteen thousand scudi, and
then would not carry out the work he had undertaken.
Neither the one nor the other was true, because he had from
Julius for the Tomb only one thousand ducats, spent in
those months of quarrying marble at Carrara. How then
could Michael Angelo have received money for it from him,
since he changed his purpose and would hear no more of
the Tomb? As to the money Michael Angelo received,
after the death of Pope Julius, from the two cardinals,
his executors, Michael Angelo possesses a written public
acknowledgment—by the hand of a notary, from Bernardo
Bini, Florentine citizen, who was trustee, and payed out
the money—that the payments amounted to about three
thousand ducats. Never was man more anxious about his
work than Michael Angelo in this, as much because he
knew how great fame it would bring him as for the loving
memory in which he always held the blessed spirit of Pope
Julius, for that reason he has always honoured and loved the
House della Rovere, and especially the Dukes of Urbino,
for that reason he has contended with two Popes, as has
LIII. But returning to Pope Paul. I must tell you
that after the last agreement made between his Excellency
the Duke and Michael Angelo, the Pope took Michael
Angelo into his service, and desired him to carry out what
he had begun in the time of Clement, to paint the end
wall of the Sistine Chapel, which he had already covered
with rough-cast and screened off with boards from floor to
ceiling. As this work was instigated by Pope Clement,
and begun in his time, it does not bear the arms of Paul,
although he desired it; but Pope Paul so loved and
reverenced Michael Angelo that however much he desired
it he would never have vexed him. In this work Michael
Angelo expressed all that the human figure is capable of
in the art of painting, not leaving out any pose or action
whatsoever. The composition is careful and well thought
out, but lengthy to describe; perhaps it is unnecessary, as
so many engravings and such a variety of drawings of it
have been dispersed everywhere. Nevertheless, for those
who have not seen the real thing, and into whose hands
the engravings have not come, let us say, briefly, that
the whole is divided into parts, right and left, upper and
lower, and central. In the central part, near to the earth,
are seven angels, described by Saint John in the Apocalypse,
with trumpets to their lips, calling the dead to
judgment from the four corners of the earth. With them
are two others having an open book in their hands, in
which every one reads and recognises his past life, having
almost to judge himself. At the sound of these trumpets